Wednesday, December 23, 2009

December 15, 2009 - Blood River

On December 16, 1838, 430 gun-toting Boers defeated an army of 10,000 spear-waving Zulu warriors, killing 3,000 of the Zulus, proving the superiority of gunpowder over spears, and turning the water of the Ncombe River red, giving rise to the name Blood River. Miraculously, during the battle none of the Boers were killed and only 3 were injured. The Boers attributed their victory to the vow they made before the battle to build a church and hold the day sacred if they won. Generations of Afrikaners (white South Africans of Dutch extraction) interpreted the unlikely victory at Blood River as a sign of the superiority of the white man. The events at Blood River are at the heart of Afrikaner nationalism, which was central to Apartheid ideology.

When the Afrikaners ran South Africa, December 16th was declared a religious public holiday. They called it Dingane Day, which translates loosely as "the day we kicked their black asses." It doesn't take a lot of imagination to see how that might be considered offensive by the vast majority of the population here. After a few decades, the name was changed to Covenant Day, which translates loosely as "the day God looked down and chose the white man to run this country." It isn't surprising that one of the first acts of the post-apartheid government was to rename the public holiday the Day of Reconciliation.

When we read in our guide book that the monument at Blood River was comprised of 64 life-size bronze Voortrekker wagons, we decided that we couldn't miss seeing such a vainglorious, quasi-religious monument. Realizing that we could be there on the eve of the Covenant Day holiday, which is still celebrated by Afrikaners, we hustled on over to see what was doing. Unfortunately, we might have been hustling a little too fast, as we skidded off the gravel road leading out to the battlefield at 80km/hr and landed in a cow pasture. We got out to inspect the car and make sure we hadn't punctured anything and found that our legs were shaking from the adrenaline dump.

Riders waving old flags - Dutch Empire, Anglo-Boer War Unity Flag, New Republic (Vryheid), Transval Republic, Orange Free State, Natalia Republic. The new South African national flag is conspicuously absent.

We were still rattled from the near miss when we arrived at the Blood River Monument Site to find a group of 30 riders, dressed in khaki, sitting astride their horses, carrying the flags of the old Afrikaner Free States, preparing to go through the entrance gate. Sten pulled around them and began to enter the gate. Then he froze.

Sitting in the car halted in front of the gate, I looked at the crowd of white people in front of us wearing khaki and bonnets and holding cameras. I looked at the line of riders behind us. Then I turned to Sten and said, "Dude, you're holding up the parade." He jolted into action and drove us through the gates, leading the parade.

We got out of the car and watched the rest of the parade, which was kicking off several days of festivities. In the parking lot several dozen tents and campers were already set up and the braais were going. Initially we were welcomed in Afrikans, but when we responded in our American-accented English people seemed taken aback to find outsiders among them. We were clearly intruding on something sacred to them, and possibly something that they didn't want to be seen doing by anyone else. I felt like we had infiltrated a Klan rally. So we paid our entrance fee, watched an informative, if somewhat skewed movie about the battle, and headed over to the life-size laager (defensive formation) of bronze wagons.

If that isn't anachronistic, I don't know what is.

Once we were inside the wagon circle we could see a huge crowd on the other side of the river, on the other side of the razor wire-topped chain link fence that surrounds the Blood River Monument. We could see large tents set up in front of a large, low-slung brick building. We assumed that the building that we were looking at was the Ncombe Monument and Museum Complex, which was built after the end of Apartheid to tell the Zulu side of the story about the events that occurred at Blood River. We debated whether we had time to make a stop there as well, but then we decided that we really had to check it out.

As we drove through the gates, we got a lot of odd looks from the Zulus attending the Reconciliation Day festivities at Ncombe. Their expressions said "whitey, you are on the wrong side of the river." Or maybe we were just projecting our own fears onto their surprised faces. We parked and walked through the crowd towards the entrance of the museum, causing a lot of double takes, as people swung their heads around to give us a second look.

At the museum entrance, we were greeted with more wondering expressions and a smile. We were assigned two guides wearing orange safety vests to walk through the empty museum with us. We asked them a few questions, but they didn't speak much English. At the far end of the exhibits, we reached an open door, leading out to the back of the complex, through which we could hear singing. Our guides gestured us back towards the door we came in, but we asked if we could go out and see what was going on. So they led us out the back door and into a crowd of a thousand Zulus watching a dance performance.

First stop was to see their boss, who greeted us with a traditional handshake. Then, they tried to lead us into the tent for honored guests. We didn't want to be on display, or to disrupt the proceedings, so we motioned that we wanted to stand on the sidelines with the rest of the crowd and watch the dancing.
Zulus dancing under the new South African Flag

As bare breasted maidens wearing wool skirts sang and clapped to keep the beat, boys wearing t-shirts and imitation lion fur around their calves, above their Converse All Stars, danced energetically. As a precisely synchronized group, they executed a well-choreographed routine of high kicks, claps, jumps, and falls on their backsides. Our favorite part was the minister wearing a big silver cross and waving a briefcase directing the whole show.

As we watched the performance, we noted that we were the only white people there. Even on the sidelines, we were a complete spectacle. Everyone around us was looking at us, rather than the dancers. The girls glanced at us surreptitiously, then twittered with each other. The boys stared openly. I tried to strike up a conversation with the young man standing next to me, but he didn't respond; I assume because he didn't speak much English.

Trying to be less conspicuous, I sat down on the ground behind some older women. Sten squatted behind me. The ladies kept gesturing for us to come sit in front of them. Thinking that there might still be a few people on the parade ground who weren't aware of our presence, and wanting to keep it that way, we declined. One of the older women spoke some English and asked why we wouldn't go sit in the tent at the front of the performance ground. We said that we weren't staying long and didn't want to bother anyone. Well, that wasn't good enough.

She gathered herself up, grabbed my hand and pulled me to my feet. Towing me through the tightly packed crowd, with Sten following behind, she led us towards the tent. Sten thought that it was for our protection; I thought that she was just being hospitable. We had to explain to a guard why we didn't want to sit at the front of the crowd or go into the tent. The guard calmed down our new auntie, and we watched the rest of the performance from the sidelines. At the end, Sten let out a hoot of approval, which got some laughs from the people around us.

As we drove away, we realized that we had just witnessed a microcosm of this racially troubled nation. Here we were, ostensibly on the eve of the Day of Reconciliation. And yet, no one is reconciled. The two races are still camped out on different sides of the river.


Ron. said...

The people whom you are talking about here are the Boer people. Not the Afrikaners. The term Afrikaner was cooked up by some Cape Dutch intellectuals at Paarl [ a region that the Boers' ancestors trekked away from long before they were known as Boers ] in the late 19th cent at a time when most of the Boers were independent within their Boer Republics. The term Afrikaner is simply political mythology that was aimed at lumping the smaller Boer people in with the numerically larger Cape Dutch after the second Anglo-Boer War.

No. The Boers & neither most of the Afrikaners are "of Dutch extraction". This was yet another lie by the elite in order to deny the ethnicity of the Boer people. The Boers are of German / Frisian / Danish & French Huguenot origin. There are some Dutch roots but that is found more among the Cape Dutch Afrikaners. The Boers developed on the Cape frontier away from the Cape Dutch. A lot of German Protestants settled directly on the Cape frontier where the Boer developed.

Afrikaner Nationalism was created entirely by the Afrikaner Broederbond which was a very small special interest group which hijacked their way into power by first hijacking Boer history & heritage while often omitting their own Cape Dutch roots [ as pointed out by authors like Sheila Patterson ] all under the dispossessing rubric of the Afrikaner term. Professor Wallace Mills notes how the Boers were different from the Cape Dutch of the western Cape region.

The point of the the Day of the Vow was to give THANKS for being spared. Not about gloating over a victory & it has NOTHING to do with racialism as the Boers would have had to defend themselves even if they were being attacked by European powers which they have had to do as well. Try to remember that the Zulus had killed 500 Boer civilians & children at Bloukrans earlier that year right after they also killed Piet Retief & his 70 member delegation.

Therefore one must view this battle in its proper perspective. The Zulus are not the "majority" of the population. No ethnic group has a majority in South Africa. Furthermore the Boers & Zulus have reconciled A LONG TIME ago back when they both exchanged Rocks of Peace in 1840 & came together again on the banks of the Ncome River in 1866 to stack rocks as a symbol of reconciliation.

Ron. said...

The Boers & Zulus have been allied together many times after this famous battle. Pretorius & King Mpande were in an alliance. King Dinuzulu gave the Boers of the ZAR a tract of land in the Northern Natal as payment for hiring the Boers to help him tackle a pro-British Zulu faction. The Vryheid Republic was established in 1884 on this land which the modern Zulus in fact STILL recognize as belonging to the Boers as they publicly stated in a CODESA like meeting back in 1985. The notion that the Boers & Zulus are irreconcilables is simply at odds with the truth & I suspect that you promote your assertion in order to stir the pot.

Then you misidentify the Cape Rebel flag as supposedly the Transvaal Republic flag. The ZAR flag has a red top bar not an orange top bar. You say that the new South African flag is conspicuously absent while forgetting that it has no place as a Boer flag. The Boer people will naturally be using Boer flags. You will notice that the old South African flag is also conspicuously absent as that flag too is not a Boer flag [ click on this link to learn more about this ] & was adopted by the Cape Dutch Prime Minister JBM Hertzog. [ Despite his siding with & fighting for the Boers in the Anglo-Boer War. ] The new South African flag simply represents the SAME mega State that the old South African flag represented. A State that was created on the backs of 24 000 dead Boer children in the British concentration camps.

The Afrikaners had no states. Those were the Boer Republics you are talking about. The Cape Dutch Afrikaners ridiculed the Boers for going on the Great Trek & presumed that they would all die in short order. Try to learn more about this topic before spouting off. The fact that the Boers & Zulus celebrate the day on different sides of the river is due to cultural realities not due to a lack of reconciliation.

Ron. said...

For an extensive list of excerpts of notable figures recognizing the important distinction of Boer from Afrikaner click on the preceding link.

For more regarding the distinction between Boer & Afrikaner click on this link to an excerpt of an interview done with Theuns Cloete of Boervolk Radio from 2007.

For more on The Persistent Blind Spot concerning the regular omission of the larger Cape Dutch population click on the informative preceding link.

Ron. said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ron. said...

The Boers & Zulus are BOTH oppressed under the Afrikaner & Xhosa domination of South African society & both groups want exactly the same thing: self determination. But foreigners like you will never stop to misrepresent both of them & distort in order to create false acrimony so as to justify the destruction of both & the force of the South African State. I think you are just projecting.